Game as work, or Game as relaxation?

It’s the fundamental conflict between gamers. You have two kinds.

1. The gamer who engages the MMO fully, researching builds, tracking DPS, understanding the game’s prevailling culture and meeting it’s demands.

2. The gamer who engages the MMO casually, exploring, not delving deeply into mechanics, but instead doing less rewarding or meaningful content at his own pace.

Gamer #1 is engaging the game as Work. This is not to say he is drudging or grinding, but the purpose of work is to achieve an end goal and receive reward or adulation. Work is task-oriented and involves conforming the individual to an outside system in order to get those rewards. In MMOs that system is a hybrid of both the game mechanics and the player community.

Gamer #2 is engaging the game as Relaxation. Relaxation is centered around the individual and isn’t goal-oriented. If anything, the purpose is to forget pre-existing goals and reach a flow state similar to Buddhist mindlessness. Ironically, while you submit to an outside system when you work, you retain yourself and your goals and ego. In relaxation the goal is to forget those.

These two gamers are the archetypes of the two sides of conflict in designing. Things that aid the relaxer are often meaningless to the worker, because they don’t aid in reaching goals, reward, or adulation. Things that aid the worker often disrupt the zen needed for a relaxer to lose himself in the game. When the two clash over limited resources, it’s quite a conflict.

While people mayplace themselves in between these two extremes, most identify with one side or the other. Which side do you see yourself as?

Advertisements

3 Responses to Game as work, or Game as relaxation?

  1. Tesh says:

    I’m certainly a Relaxer when I play, but as a dev, I can’t help but notice the game design systems in a game. It’s sort of like how I can’t fully just Relax by watching a movie; I’m trained to make animated movies, so I’ll notice all the technical things that make the movie work (or not). It’s extremely hard to just go with the flow.

    That said, I am always hoping to relax. I get enough work at work… and I get paid for it. I don’t need it in my very few hours of free time.

  2. Dblade says:

    Work isn’t always negative though. You can find entertainment in that, but it’s just adifferent mode. Some people really enjoy the number crunching and reverse engineering of theory craft.

    I do agree on evaluating, it can suck the enjoyment out of even the best works.

  3. Tesh says:

    True enough. Work is good for you. It’s just not what I’m really looking for in my games. Volleyball, though, that’s “free time”, and I do love a good workout. 😉

    I do even like some number crunching… just when it’s optional. Time sinks I have little patience with. *shrug*

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: